CONGREGATION SHEARITH ISRAEL
  • About
    • Mission, Vision, Core Values
    • Become a Member >
      • Membership Brochure
    • Our Congregation and History
    • Blog
    • People >
      • Meet our Klei Kodesh
      • Meet our Staff
      • Meet our Lay Leadership
    • Places >
      • Shul Locations
      • Shearith Israel Cemeteries
      • Family Room
    • Communications >
      • The Shofar: Nov 2020 - Jan 2021
      • Program Guide January - July 2021
      • Shearith Social Media
      • Sign up for our emails!
  • Connect
    • Let's Go Live >
      • Virtual Study Guides and Liturgy >
        • Shiva Minyan Liturgy
        • Our Favorite Jewish Stories Study Guide
        • The New Jewish Canon
        • Torah of Social Distancing Study Materials
        • Torah on Tap Study Materials
        • Shabbat Morning Torah Study Guides
        • Women's Torah Study Materials
      • Let's Go Live How To's
      • Updates on our Response to COVID-19
    • Get in Touch
    • Groups >
      • 20s and 30s
      • College Connection
      • Pillars: Hazak Community
      • Shearith Prime
      • Shearith Community Youth
      • Social Action
    • Family Center >
      • Family Center Program and Event Descriptions
      • Tiny Treasures
    • The Ladder Project >
      • Donors to The Ladder Project
    • Music at Shearith >
      • Shabbat Musical Experiences
      • Small-Waldman-Cohen Signature Series
      • Hazzan Zhrebker Music
      • Our Shearith Choirs
    • SISterhood >
      • SISterhood Programs and Events
      • SISterhood Gallery Judaica Giftshop
      • SISterhood Board Forms
  • Pray
    • Shabbat and Minyan Times and Liturgy
    • Shearith Beyond
    • Livestream from Beck Family Sanctuary
    • Alternative Prayer Experiences
    • Holidays >
      • Purim and Mishloach Manot
    • Shabbat Musical Experiences
    • Refresh
    • Lifecycle >
      • Birth
      • B'nei Mitzvah
      • Conversion
      • Wedding
      • End of Life >
        • End of Life Info
        • Shearith Israel Cemeteries
      • Recent Passings/Yahrzeits
      • Yahrzeit Update Form
    • Misheberach (Healing)
    • Torah >
      • Torah and Haftarah Readings
      • Holiday Torah and Haftarah Readings
  • Lifelong Learning
    • The Weitzman Family Religious School >
      • WFRS 20-21 Registration
      • WFRS K- 7 Calendar
      • DeReKH
      • WFRS Curriculum
    • B'nei Mitzvah
    • Adult Learning Calendar >
      • Adult Learning Class Descriptions >
        • NEW: Together & Apart: The Future of Jewish Peoplehood
    • Kesher (Special Needs) Program
  • Membership
    • Membership Portal
    • Update Your Membership Portal
    • Become A Member
  • Give
  • Our Full Calendar
  • The Gallery at Shearith Israel

12/3/2019

Scarcity and Abundance and Giving Thanks

1 Comment

Read Now
 
Picture
A sermon by Rabbi Adam Roffman
​Among the tales in the Roffman family lore is a story about my brother who, when he was very young, before I was born, went out to eat one night with my parents. It was February and the restaurant had been releasing, a week at a time, commemorative plates featuring the faces of the great American presidents.  That week, they honored our 16th president, drawn, as usual, in his impressively tall top hat.
 
“Do you know who that is?” my parents asked my brother.
 
“Yes!” he answered.  “That’s Abraham Lincoln!  He freed the slabes!”
 
No, that’s not a typo. S-l-a-b-e-s. Slabes.
 
And then he said: “And that’s why we celebrate Thanksgiving!”
 
I think of that story often this time of year, as I reflect on the meaning of a holiday that holds great significance for American Jews. After all, we have a lot to be thankful for, living in the greatest diaspora community in the history of our people, afforded the rights and privileges denied to us for so many years.
 
And yet, because we are taught that expressing our gratitude through prayer and ritual is one of the fundamental tasks of daily Jewish life, it seems a little odd that we should celebrate that gratitude on any one day of the year.  Is there something more to the nature of this holiday that might help us understand why this day of thanks is, as we say, different from all other days of thanksgiving? And is that “something” also reflected in our tradition?
 
Turns out—the answer is yes.
 
One of the most famous symbols of Thanksgiving is the cornucopia, or horn of plenty.  We’ve all seen pictures, no doubt, of the basket with a narrow opening that leads to a widening passage filled with the fruits of the season, gourds and grains that are so abundant they spill out of the end of the horn. 
 
As I reread the account of the story of the first Thanksgiving, I realized why both ends of the horn have something to teach us about why those Pilgrims and Puritans were so grateful in 1621. 
 
In his account of those difficult first few years off of Massachusetts Bay, Of Plymouth Plantation, William Bradford writes:
 
“The Lord sent them such seasonable showers, with interchange of fair warm weather as, through His blessing, caused a fruitful and liberal harvest, to their no small comfort and rejoicing. For which mercy, in time convenient, they also set apart a day of thanksgiving… By this time harvest was come, and instead of famine now God gave them plenty … for which they blessed God.”
 
The Englishmen who arrived on these shores were expecting something very different from what they found—a land of plenty, with ample resources to build and sustain a growing colony that would generate wealth and prosperity.  Instead, they encountered harsh winters, disease, and famine.  It wasn’t until the Native-American Squanto taught them how to grow corn that the land delivered on its promise and devastating hunger was replaced overwhelming gratitude at the abundance that now adorned their very full tables.
 
Like the horn of plenty, those who experienced that first Thanksgiving had known both a narrow, difficult beginning, and a seemingly infinite and expansive present and future now that the vastness and potential of the American landscape was revealed to them. This potential led them and their descendants to spread out as far as their ambition, hard work, and sacrifice could take them, filling their bellies and their pocketbooks with the rewards of the richness of this country.
 
And yet, we know that the widening of their enterprise came at a great cost for those who had lived for generations on that same land.  Eventually, when you spread out as far as you can go, either you will run out of room or you will have to dispossess others of what they own in order to satisfy your own appetite.
 
We Jews also know a great deal about the challenges of moving from scarcity to abundance, from the narrowness of the meitzar (the root of the Hebrew word for Egypt), to the blessings of a land filled with milk and honey.
 
In last week’s parasha, Toldot, our patriarch Isaac also runs into some trouble when he tries to expand his territory.  In the unfriendly confines of the territory of the Philistines, the wells which were rightly his, an inheritance from Isaac’s father who dug them, were stopped up. Isaac successfully reopens them, but when he finds new source of mayim hayim, living waters, the locals challenge his right to this most precious resource in the arid land of Canaan.
 
Eventually, Isaac manages to wrestle away a well of his very own—one he names, appropriately, with gratitude to God, Rehovot­, the wide-open spaces.
 
Still, if our sense of gratitude is dependent on our ability to constantly expand outward, to possess more and more, what happens when that isn’t possible or isn’t ethical? If we are only able to say “thank you” when we have more, how will we maintain our gratitude to God when we, inevitably, have less?
                                                       
One of the rabbinic teachings frequently mentioned this time of year comes from Pirkei Avot: “Who is rich? The one who is satisfied with his portion.” Rabbi Jonah Gerundi explains further:
 
“Anyone who is not happy with his lot and is not satisfied with what God, may He be blessed, gave him is a poor person; as it is explained in the verse (Proverbs 15:15), "All the days of a poor man are bad, but one with a good heart has a constant feast." This teaches that all the days of a 'poor man,’ one who desires only money are bad, for ‘a lover of money never has his fill of money': but all the days of the one with a good heart, who is happy with his lot, are good [as the one] one who makes a constant feast.”
 
Gerundi ingeniously understands the terms “rich” and “poor” to be not indicative of the balance of one’s bank account, or the size of one’s home, or the breadth of one’s holdings, but of the condition of one’s spirit. 
 
If all we desire is to “widen” what we already have, if that is the only thing that gives us satisfaction, then we do not understand the meaning of the word gratitude.  If, on the other hand, we can learn to temper our desire to constantly expand, or use that desire to do good for others, those whose lot is still narrow, then we will truly be able to share in a Thanksgiving that is both authentically American and unmistakably Jewish. 

Share

1 Comment
Joel link
12/7/2019 09:11:57 pm

I enjoy reading your remarks, as well as Shira's, i remember you both as prominent students at jts and very well liked in community. Keep up excellent writing, it is.educational, insightful, and i can envision myself in some of anecdotes as i had similar life experiences.
Joel

Reply



Leave a Reply.

Details

    Authors

    Shearith Israel  clergy, staff and congregants share
    ​their stories. 

    Archives

    November 2020
    September 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    December 2019
    October 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017

    Categories

    All
    Annual Meeting
    DeReKH
    Family Center
    Guest Bloggers
    Holidays
    Israel
    Let's Go Live
    Marcy Helfand
    Prayer
    Rabbi Adam Roffman
    Rabbi Ari Sunshine
    Rabbi Matt Rutta
    Rabbi Shira Wallach
    Rosh Hashanah
    Rosh Hashanah 5779
    Sarah Lipinsky
    Social Justice
    The Ladder Project
    Traditions
    Worship
    Yom Kippur

    RSS Feed

9401 Douglas Avenue Dallas, TX 75225
​214-361-6606
© COPYRIGHT 2020. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.
  • About
    • Mission, Vision, Core Values
    • Become a Member >
      • Membership Brochure
    • Our Congregation and History
    • Blog
    • People >
      • Meet our Klei Kodesh
      • Meet our Staff
      • Meet our Lay Leadership
    • Places >
      • Shul Locations
      • Shearith Israel Cemeteries
      • Family Room
    • Communications >
      • The Shofar: Nov 2020 - Jan 2021
      • Program Guide January - July 2021
      • Shearith Social Media
      • Sign up for our emails!
  • Connect
    • Let's Go Live >
      • Virtual Study Guides and Liturgy >
        • Shiva Minyan Liturgy
        • Our Favorite Jewish Stories Study Guide
        • The New Jewish Canon
        • Torah of Social Distancing Study Materials
        • Torah on Tap Study Materials
        • Shabbat Morning Torah Study Guides
        • Women's Torah Study Materials
      • Let's Go Live How To's
      • Updates on our Response to COVID-19
    • Get in Touch
    • Groups >
      • 20s and 30s
      • College Connection
      • Pillars: Hazak Community
      • Shearith Prime
      • Shearith Community Youth
      • Social Action
    • Family Center >
      • Family Center Program and Event Descriptions
      • Tiny Treasures
    • The Ladder Project >
      • Donors to The Ladder Project
    • Music at Shearith >
      • Shabbat Musical Experiences
      • Small-Waldman-Cohen Signature Series
      • Hazzan Zhrebker Music
      • Our Shearith Choirs
    • SISterhood >
      • SISterhood Programs and Events
      • SISterhood Gallery Judaica Giftshop
      • SISterhood Board Forms
  • Pray
    • Shabbat and Minyan Times and Liturgy
    • Shearith Beyond
    • Livestream from Beck Family Sanctuary
    • Alternative Prayer Experiences
    • Holidays >
      • Purim and Mishloach Manot
    • Shabbat Musical Experiences
    • Refresh
    • Lifecycle >
      • Birth
      • B'nei Mitzvah
      • Conversion
      • Wedding
      • End of Life >
        • End of Life Info
        • Shearith Israel Cemeteries
      • Recent Passings/Yahrzeits
      • Yahrzeit Update Form
    • Misheberach (Healing)
    • Torah >
      • Torah and Haftarah Readings
      • Holiday Torah and Haftarah Readings
  • Lifelong Learning
    • The Weitzman Family Religious School >
      • WFRS 20-21 Registration
      • WFRS K- 7 Calendar
      • DeReKH
      • WFRS Curriculum
    • B'nei Mitzvah
    • Adult Learning Calendar >
      • Adult Learning Class Descriptions >
        • NEW: Together & Apart: The Future of Jewish Peoplehood
    • Kesher (Special Needs) Program
  • Membership
    • Membership Portal
    • Update Your Membership Portal
    • Become A Member
  • Give
  • Our Full Calendar
  • The Gallery at Shearith Israel