Congregation Shearith Israel
  • About
    • Mission, Vision, Core Values
    • Contact Us
    • Our Congregation and History
    • Blog
    • Places >
      • Shul Locations
      • David A. Segal Family Simcha Play Center
      • Shearith Israel Cemeteries
      • Family Room
    • People >
      • Klei Kodesh
      • Staff
      • Lay Leadership
    • SHEARITH.LIVE
    • Communications >
      • Shearith People
      • The Shofar
      • Our Video Channel
      • Shearith Social Media
      • Sign up for our emails!
  • Calendar
  • Connect
    • Study Guides >
      • Shabbat Morning Torah Study Guides
      • Thursdays with the Rabbis Study Guides
      • Women's Torah Study Materials
    • Travel to Israel with Shearith
    • Volunteer
    • Get in Touch
    • Groups >
      • 20s and 30s
      • College Connection
      • Pillars: Hazak Community
      • Shearith Prime
      • Social Action
    • Family Center >
      • Family Center Program and Event Descriptions
      • Tiny Treasures
      • Family Shabbat Retreat
    • Music at Shearith >
      • Shabbat Musical Experiences
      • Small-Waldman-Cohen Signature Series
      • Hazzan Zhrebker Music
      • Our Shearith Choirs
      • Service From the Heart Album
    • The Ladder Project >
      • Donors to The Ladder Project
    • SISterhood >
      • Programs and Events
      • Torah Fund
      • The Gallery
      • SISterhood Board Forms
  • Pray
    • Shabbat and Minyan Times and Liturgy
    • Alternative Prayer Experiences
    • Holidays
    • Shabbat Musical Experiences
    • Lifecycle >
      • Birth
      • B'nei Mitzvah >
        • Adult B'nei Mitzvah
      • Conversion
      • Wedding
      • End of Life >
        • End of Life Info
        • Shearith Israel Cemeteries
      • Passings/Yahrzeits
      • Shiva Minyan Liturgy
    • Misheberach (Healing)
    • Torah >
      • Torah and Haftarah Readings
      • Holiday Torah and Haftarah Readings
  • Learn
    • The Weitzman Family Religious School >
      • WFRS Registration
      • WFRS Curriculum
      • WFRS K- 7 Calendar
      • Kesher (Special Needs) Program
    • B'nei Mitzvah
    • Adult Learning >
      • Overview
      • Class Calendar
      • Class Descriptions
      • ScholarStream Classes
  • Membership
    • Welcome
    • Types of Membership
    • Online Application
    • Update ShulCloud Account
    • Membership Portal
    • Directory
  • GIVE
    • Opportunities
    • Annual Campaign
    • Donate
  • Foundation
    • Mission and Board
    • Gifting Opportunities
    • Legacy Donors

1/9/2019

To Disagree is Jewish. To Disengage is Not.

2 Comments

Read Now
 
Picture
My heart sank as I read the headline of an article from the Forward on my Facebook feed this week: “Even Proud Zionists Think This Hillel Is Way Too Focused On Israel.”
 
Before I even clicked on the link to see the details, I knew what the story would, essentially, be about—young Jews, whose disagreements about Israel were polarizing a Jewish community. 

​Though many people believe that American’s Judaism most daunting challenge is demographics, I believe that the nightmare scenario for our people in the coming generations will center around division, not addition or subtraction.
 
I fear a Jewish landscape where there are synagogues that are either red or blue, AIPAC or J-Street, or, as seems to be the case on Northeastern University Campus, Hillels where Israel is a welcome topic of conversation, or Jewish affinity groups where Zionism is too controversial a topic to be broached.
 
To be fair to the students at Northeastern, a Boston University with a population of more than 1,500 Jews, their complaint didn’t necessarily stem from a particular stance or lack of political or historical nuance reflected in the Israel programming at their Hillel, but rather, from an imbalance in its offerings.  The fact that the entire student board was summarily dismissed for signing a letter “complaining that the Hillel staff was too focused on Israel and not enough on things like celebrating Jewish holidays or studying Jewish texts,” is a disturbing claim.  But the solution of one student, creating an entirely new organization, the Jewish Student Union, as a “safe haven” for students who don’t want Israel on the menu is, perhaps, even more frightening.
 
Effectively, by taking their chips off the table and going elsewhere, these students aren’t just isolating themselves from Hillel’s unabashedly pro-Israel voice, they are isolating themselves from any opportunity to engage with Israel. To be sure, much of the current generation of Jewish college students struggles to understand Israel’s policies and, tragically, Zionism itself, to a greater extent than their parents or grandparents do.  And certainly, the answer isn’t to demonize these young Jews or to call them naïve or deny them a seat at the table. Because if we alienate them, we run the risk of estranging them from both Israel and the Jewish community as a whole.
 
But too often, Jews fall into the trap of thinking that we should deal with our discomforting disagreements about Israel in the same way we deal with our unease about the American political divide.  Either we segment ourselves into an echo chamber that reinforces our own opinion, or we shut down the conversation all together.
 
As American families, we can do that. We can pretend that when we’re gathered together around the dinner table that our political differences don’t exist.  
 
But as Jewish families, as Jewish communities, we can’t.
 
We can’t cut ourselves off from other Jews, or give up on engaging with other Jews simply because we don’t agree, especially when it comes to Israel. Why? Because America’s story will go on whether we talk to each other about it or not. And Israel’s story needs each and every one of us in the conversation in order to survive.
 
Judaism has always been a conversation between two (or more!) sides. That’s what the Mishnah is, that’s what the Talmud is, and critical scholarship of the Bible has revealed that this is even what the Torah is.
 
When the conversation dies, so do we.

Share

2 Comments
DARREN WOLFE
1/10/2019 05:48:54 pm

If this is the direction of Northeastern University or the overall attitude of students at university look no further then the rabbis, professors & leaders of JTS. They have been teaching and instructing this generation since kindergarten.

Reply
Robert L Book
1/10/2019 08:30:57 pm

If Jewish students are "fired" for asking a Jewish organization to spend more time on Jewish texts and practice, what else could they possibly do other than find another organization?

Reply



Leave a Reply.

Details

    Authors

    Shearith Israel  clergy, staff and congregants share
    ​their stories. 

    Archives

    April 2023
    March 2023
    January 2023
    December 2022
    November 2022
    December 2021
    October 2021
    June 2021
    November 2020
    September 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    December 2019
    October 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017

    Categories

    All
    Annual Meeting
    DeReKH
    Family Center
    Guest Bloggers
    Holidays
    Israel
    Let's Go Live
    Marcy Helfand
    Prayer
    Rabbi Adam Roffman
    Rabbi Ari Sunshine
    Rabbi Matt Rutta
    Rabbi Shira Wallach
    Rosh Hashanah
    Rosh Hashanah 5779
    Sarah Lipinsky
    Social Action
    Social Justice
    The Ladder Project
    Traditions
    Worship
    Yom Kippur

    RSS Feed

© COPYRIGHT 2020. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.
  • About
    • Mission, Vision, Core Values
    • Contact Us
    • Our Congregation and History
    • Blog
    • Places >
      • Shul Locations
      • David A. Segal Family Simcha Play Center
      • Shearith Israel Cemeteries
      • Family Room
    • People >
      • Klei Kodesh
      • Staff
      • Lay Leadership
    • SHEARITH.LIVE
    • Communications >
      • Shearith People
      • The Shofar
      • Our Video Channel
      • Shearith Social Media
      • Sign up for our emails!
  • Calendar
  • Connect
    • Study Guides >
      • Shabbat Morning Torah Study Guides
      • Thursdays with the Rabbis Study Guides
      • Women's Torah Study Materials
    • Travel to Israel with Shearith
    • Volunteer
    • Get in Touch
    • Groups >
      • 20s and 30s
      • College Connection
      • Pillars: Hazak Community
      • Shearith Prime
      • Social Action
    • Family Center >
      • Family Center Program and Event Descriptions
      • Tiny Treasures
      • Family Shabbat Retreat
    • Music at Shearith >
      • Shabbat Musical Experiences
      • Small-Waldman-Cohen Signature Series
      • Hazzan Zhrebker Music
      • Our Shearith Choirs
      • Service From the Heart Album
    • The Ladder Project >
      • Donors to The Ladder Project
    • SISterhood >
      • Programs and Events
      • Torah Fund
      • The Gallery
      • SISterhood Board Forms
  • Pray
    • Shabbat and Minyan Times and Liturgy
    • Alternative Prayer Experiences
    • Holidays
    • Shabbat Musical Experiences
    • Lifecycle >
      • Birth
      • B'nei Mitzvah >
        • Adult B'nei Mitzvah
      • Conversion
      • Wedding
      • End of Life >
        • End of Life Info
        • Shearith Israel Cemeteries
      • Passings/Yahrzeits
      • Shiva Minyan Liturgy
    • Misheberach (Healing)
    • Torah >
      • Torah and Haftarah Readings
      • Holiday Torah and Haftarah Readings
  • Learn
    • The Weitzman Family Religious School >
      • WFRS Registration
      • WFRS Curriculum
      • WFRS K- 7 Calendar
      • Kesher (Special Needs) Program
    • B'nei Mitzvah
    • Adult Learning >
      • Overview
      • Class Calendar
      • Class Descriptions
      • ScholarStream Classes
  • Membership
    • Welcome
    • Types of Membership
    • Online Application
    • Update ShulCloud Account
    • Membership Portal
    • Directory
  • GIVE
    • Opportunities
    • Annual Campaign
    • Donate
  • Foundation
    • Mission and Board
    • Gifting Opportunities
    • Legacy Donors